Constitutional Amendments: Processes and Challenges

0
230

Constitutional amendments are changes or additions to an existing constitution that may be necessary to keep up with the changing times and needs. In order for an amendment to become part of the U.S. Constitution, the amendment must pass through several processes and there are associated challenges along the way. This article will discuss the overall process of amending the Constitution as well as the various challenges which this process is faced with.

The Process of Constitutional Amendment 

The fundamental process for amending the Constitution of the United States consists of three steps – this is also known as the Madisonian Model of Amendment. This Model was devised by James Madison and describes the processes for assessing whether or not changing the Constitution is necessary, initiating the needed amendment, and ensuring that it is accepted and adopted by the states. The basic steps are as follows:

  1. Proposal of an Amendment: An amendment to the Constitution can be proposed either by Congress (with two-thirds majority vote) or by a Constitutional Convention that is called for by two-thirds of the state legislatures.

  2. Ratification of the Amendment: Once an amendment has been proposed, it then needs to be ratified by either three-fourths of the states (through either state legislatures or conventions) or by the American people in a national referendum.

  3. Incorporation into the Constitution: Once the amendment has been ratified, it is then incorporated into the U.S. Constitution and becomes part of the supreme law of the land.

Challenges of Constitutional Amendment Process 

The process of amending the Constitution involves several complicated steps and can be a long and drawn-out process. In some cases, it can take decades for an amendment to be passed and implemented; for example, the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA) has been around for almost half a century yet still remains unratified. The process also has a number of inherent challenges, including but not limited to the following:

  1. Geographical Disputes: Geographical disputes among the states can be a major impediment to the successful ratification of a proposed amendment. If one section of the country is strongly in favor of an amendment while another is strongly against it, it can be difficult to attain the necessary three-fourths majority required for ratification.

  2. Lack of Public Support: Even if an amendment proposal has the necessary majority in Congress and in the state legislatures/conventions, it is possible that it will fail due to lack of public support. National referendums need to win the backing of the majority of the American people in order to be accepted; if an amendment fails to win the people’s support, then it will never be ratified.

  3. Legal Challenges: At times, there may be legal or constitutional questions that arise over the validity or appropriateness of a proposed amendment. These matters can tie up the amendment process for many years as the courts must have time to consider and analyze the question before rendering a verdict.

  4. Political Objections: Another challenge that can arise during the process of amending the Constitution is that of political objections. Partisan politics can skew the process of amending the Constitution and potentially impede the progress of successful ratification.

Amending the Constitution of the United States is an intricate process that requires a great amount of effort and diligence. Due to the complexities inherent to the process, it can take an extended period of time for a proposed amendment to pass. This process is faced with various challenges which can impede the successful ratification of a proposed amendment. It is important to keep in mind that ultimately ratification is up to the people, and only when the majority of the American people are in favor of an amendment will it be accepted and incorporated into the U.S. Constitution as part of the supreme law of the land.

Previous articleSpinal Nerves: Roots and Function
Next articleVatican To Send Pope Francis’ Message Of Hope Into Space